Reviewing these two commonly used workplace personality tests to help you make the right choice for you and your team.
Updated
February 14, 2024

Comparing Predictive Index to the Big Five Personality Test: Which Personality Test is Right For You?

Reviewing these two commonly used workplace personality tests to help you make the right choice for you and your team.

Reviewing these two commonly used workplace personality tests to help you make the right choice for you and your team.

👉 TL;DR

The Predictive Index (PI) and Big Five Personality Test are two distinct assessment tools. PI focuses on workplace behavior and motivation, offering insights for better team dynamics and performance. The Big Five measures five broad traits (openness, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness, and emotional stability) for personal growth and interpersonal understanding. Choosing between the two depends on the desired outcomes and specific needs of individuals or organizations.

Looking for a test to understand your team chemistry as a whole? Try TeamDynamics instead.

In this article:

Personality assessments play a crucial role in personal and professional development, offering insights into an individual's unique strengths, preferences, and behaviors. With a plethora of personality tests available, choosing the right one can be a daunting task. In this blog post, we will compare two widely used personality assessments: the Predictive Index (PI) and the Big Five Personality Test. We will delve into their histories, methodologies, strengths, weaknesses, and practical applications to help you determine which test is right for you. Furthermore, we'll discuss why these tests may not be the best fit for team settings and why TeamDynamics may be a more suitable alternative. So, let's dive in and explore the world of personality assessments!

History of the Big Five Personality Test and the Predictive Index

The Predictive Index (PI) and the Big Five Personality Test are rooted in different psychological theories and research.

The Predictive Index (PI) Personality Test was developed by Arnold S. Daniels in the 1950s as a tool for employee selection and development. Daniels based his work on William Marston's DISC theory, which focuses on behavioral styles. The PI was designed to predict workplace performance by identifying individuals' primary behavioral drives, which can help employers make more informed hiring, management, and team-building decisions.

The Big Five Personality Test (also known as OCEAN or Five Factor Model) dates back to the 1940s when researchers Raymond Cattell and Ernest Tupes started exploring the structure of personality traits. However, it wasn't until the 1980s and early 1990s that the Big Five model gained widespread recognition. Psychologists Lewis Goldberg and Robert McCrae, among others, contributed to the development and refinement of the Big Five framework, which consists of five broad dimensions: Openness, Conscientiousness, Extraversion, Agreeableness, and Neuroticism (OCEAN). The Big Five model is based on the lexical hypothesis, which posits that the most significant aspects of human personality can be identified through natural language analysis.

Both the Predictive Index and the Big Five Personality Test have evolved over time, and their popularity can be attributed to their ability to provide valuable insights into individuals' behaviors, preferences, and motivations. While their histories differ, both tests share a common goal of helping people better understand themselves and others.

Practical Applications of the Big Five Personality Test and the Predictive Index

Both the Predictive Index (PI) and the Big Five Personality Test have various practical applications across personal and professional domains. Their most common uses include:

Predictive Index (PI) Personality Test:

  1. Employee Selection: The PI is often used in the hiring process to identify candidates whose behavioral tendencies align with specific job requirements, thereby improving the likelihood of successful job performance.
  2. Talent Development: By understanding an individual's behavioral drives, managers and HR professionals can tailor employee development programs to capitalize on their strengths and address areas for improvement.
  3. Team Building: The PI can help managers create well-balanced teams by considering individuals' behavioral styles, thus improving communication, collaboration, and overall team performance.
  4. Leadership Development: The PI can provide insights into a leader's unique behavioral style, which can help them better understand their leadership approach and develop more effective management strategies.

{{inline-cta}}

Big Five Personality Test:

  1. Personal Growth: The Big Five provides individuals with insights into their personality traits, which can be useful for personal development, self-awareness, and self-improvement.
  2. Career Planning: By understanding their personality traits, individuals can identify careers that align with their strengths and preferences, thus increasing job satisfaction and success.
  3. Relationship Building: The Big Five can help individuals better understand their communication and interpersonal styles, enabling them to improve relationships with friends, family, and colleagues.
  4. Organizational Development: Organizations can use the Big Five to identify areas for development, promote a healthy work culture, and improve employee engagement and satisfaction.

While both the Predictive Index and the Big Five Personality Test offer valuable insights into an individual's behavior and preferences, their primary focus and practical applications differ. The PI is more centered around workplace performance and team dynamics, whereas the Big Five provides a broader understanding of an individual's personality traits, which can be applied across various life domains.

Strengths and Weaknesses of the Big Five Personality Test and the Predictive Index

The Predictive Index and the Big Five Personality Test are valuable tools for understanding individual behaviors, preferences, and personality traits.

Big Five Personality Index
Advantages 1. Provides a broad understanding of an individual's personality traits, which can be applied across various life domains.
2. Supported by extensive research, making it one of the most widely recognized and validated personality models.
3. Can help individuals improve relationships, communication, and interpersonal skills.
1. Focuses on workplace performance and team dynamics, making it highly relevant for organizations.
2. Assists in employee selection, development, and management, enhancing overall workplace effectiveness.
3. Identifies individuals' behavioral drives, which can help managers create well-balanced teams.
Disadvantages 1. Primarily focuses on individual traits, which may not directly address team dynamics or collective performance.
2. May not provide insights into specific workplace behaviors or preferences.
3. Less focused on team settings and may not offer actionable insights for improving team collaboration and effectiveness.
1. Limited in scope, primarily focusing on behavioral tendencies and workplace performance.
2. May not provide a comprehensive understanding of an individual's personality traits or motivations.
3. Not specifically designed for analyzing teams as a whole, which may limit its effectiveness in addressing team dynamics and collaboration.

While both the Predictive Index and the Big Five Personality Test offer valuable insights into individual behaviors and preferences, they have their limitations when it comes to analyzing and addressing team dynamics. Neither test is specifically designed to evaluate teams as a whole or provide actionable insights for improving team collaboration and effectiveness.

TeamDynamics, on the other hand, is specifically designed to assess team dynamics and help organizations optimize team performance. It evaluates factors such as communication styles, how teams process information, how teams make decisions, and how teams get work done; these actionable insights help improve team collaboration, cohesiveness, and overall effectiveness. By focusing on the collective behaviors of the team, TeamDynamics can help organizations address potential challenges, capitalize on strengths, and create well-balanced teams that work together seamlessly.

In conclusion, the Predictive Index and the Big Five Personality Test are valuable tools for understanding individual behaviors, preferences, and personality traits. However, their primary focus on individuals may limit their effectiveness in addressing team dynamics and collaboration. For organizations looking to improve team performance and optimize collaboration, TeamDynamics may be a more suitable alternative, as it is specifically designed to assess and address the unique dynamics within a team setting.

Conclusion

Both the Predictive Index (PI) and the Big Five Personality Test offer valuable insights into individual behaviors, preferences, and personality traits, with different focuses and practical applications. While the PI is more geared towards workplace performance and team dynamics, the Big Five provides a broader understanding of an individual's personality that can be applied across various life domains.

However, when it comes to analyzing and improving team dynamics, neither test may be the optimal choice. Instead, consider using TeamDynamics, a tool specifically designed to assess and address the unique dynamics within a team setting.

Ultimately, the choice between the Predictive Index, Big Five Personality Test, or TeamDynamics will depend on your specific goals and the context in which you plan to apply the insights gained. By understanding the strengths and limitations of each tool, you can make an informed decision that best serves your personal or professional development needs.

Enjoyed this read?

Get updates whenever we post more content like this. Unsubscribe anytime.

Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form. Please try again.

If that still doesn't work, please Contact Us directly.
Want to know your team's unique personality? Get a FREE analysis in just 2 minutes!

When we have team meetings…

Question 1 of 12

TeamDynamics is a tool for individuals and teams who believe that teamwork should be intentional and rewarding.

We spend just as much time today with our coworkers as we do with our loved ones. We have tools to manage our relationships with partners: love languages, compatibility tests, therapy, and more.

But when it comes to relationships with our professional teams, we’re flying blind. It doesn’t have to be that way.

Marsha F.
VP, Content Marketing

"Despite working remotely, TeamDynamics keeps our team on the same page. It's an essential tool for distributed teams and digital nomads."

David S.
Software Engineer

"When I switched teams, I felt like I lost my instincts for working with my colleagues: things that were easy to coordinate before seemed to take forever, and I couldn't get my points across. TeamDynamics helped me get my groove back."

Jennifer W.
HR Manager

"I've managed teams for two decades. Haven't seen many personality tests that can rival TeamDynamics for practicality. Notably enhanced our team's cohesion and productivity."

Discover your team's unique personality.

Invite your team and finally uncover what makes your team tick.

More like this:

Get 10% off...Get 10% off...

Do you know your team's personality? 🤔

TeamDynamics describes how your team works together and how you fit in. We'll send you a sample so you can check it out for yourself!

Success! Check your email in a few minutes.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form. Please try again.

If that still doesn't work, please Contact Us directly.
Learn More